Re: Brian... anti-EMDR?

"Eye movement's and other "bi-lateral stimulation" does not add to EMDR's effectiveness as was the result in numerous
studies. I can give you an extensive list."

Could you point me to this evidence please?

"Why waste time on things that don't add to the effectiveness of a treatment which diverts attention and resources away from better improvements? These unfounded components only seem to muddy the waters of sense and reason."

I may be just a lay-person here, but it appears you are stating that the evidence (and there is evidence to support EMDR, is there not?), found that supports EMDR is ineffectual because there is evidence that doesnt support EMDR. Couldn't you say that pretty much about all therapy?
Is there not evidence against cognitive behavioral therapy, control mastery therapy, etc. etc.?

Replies:

Research on EMDR, by Brian G., 2/10/00 Re: Research on EMDR, by Deb k, 2/11/00 Re: Research on EMDR, by Brian G., 2/11/00 Re: Research on EMDR, by , 2/12/00 Re: Research on EMDR, by , 2/12/00 Re: Research on EMDR, by Brian G., 2/12/00 Re: Research on EMDR, by M.C.(a lay person), 2/13/00 Sorry to burst your bubble!, by Brian G., 2/14/00 Re: Sorry to burst your bubble!, by Teresa, 2/14/00 Thank you Teresa!, by Brian G., 2/14/00 Re: Thank you Teresa!, by Shapiro, 2/15/00 the discussion continues, by Brian G., 2/15/00 Re: the discussion continues, by Sandra Paulsen, Ph.D., 2/16/00 Re: Thank you Teresa!, by M.C.(an EDUCATED layperson) , 3/4/00 Re: Thank you Teresa!, by Don, 3/4/00 Re: Thank you Teresa!, by M.C., 3/4/00 Re: Thank you Teresa!, by Don, 3/5/00 Re: Thank you Teresa!, by another layperson, 3/7/00 Re: Thank you Teresa!, by Brian, 3/5/00 Re: Thank you Teresa!, by Another Layperson, 3/7/00 Re: Thank you Teresa!, by Don, 3/7/00

| Behavior OnLine Home Page | Disclaimer |

Copyright © 1996-2004 Behavior OnLine, Inc. All rights reserved.