Behavior OnLine EMDR FORUM ARCHIVE, 2000

    Re:Integration of alters when working with EMDR
    leah c · 12/16/02 at 3:34 PM ET

    I wanted to clarify -- of course, integration, with five weeks of any therapy, is very good progress.

    However, without knowing what the previous treatment was like, how long it was, etc the results this client describes are only "lucky", not important. For instance, if she was in therapy for years resolving internal conflicts, then one would expect EMDR to move things forward quickly. Years of therapy would then be a substitute for the usual screening and stabilization process. If she had spent years talking through trauma, EMDR may have simply "pushed" the dissociative walls down, at the exact right moment...

    Additionally, we have no idea how long the EMDR session were, how often they were... etc... It would also be helpful to know why the client attempted emdr in the first place, what protocol was used, etc...

    Don't get me wrong, I adore EMDR, but I still fail to see how this client's experience is unique.

    Replies:
    • I will answer you questions..., by Diane, 12/17/02
      • Untoward side effect of integration, by Diane, 12/17/02
        • Re:Untoward side effect of integration, by Sandra Paulsen Inobe, PhD, 12/17/02
      • Re:I will answer you questions..., by Sandra Paulsen Inobe, PhD, 12/17/02
        • Reiki and EMDR, by Anonymous, 12/18/02
          • Oops! this response was mine - n/t, by Diane, 12/18/02
          • Re:Reiki and EMDR, by , 12/18/02
            • I have several views on this, by Diane, 12/18/02
              • Re:I have several views on this, by , 12/21/02
                • bilateral stimulation CD, by Diane, 12/24/02
                  • Re:bilateral stimulation CD, by Anonymous, 12/25/02
                  • Re:bilateral stimulation CD, by , 12/27/02
                  • bilateral stimulation CD - To Diane & Anonymous, by , 12/27/02
              • ? For Diane - Sorry about duplication, by , 12/21/02
            • Re:Reiki and EMDR, by Diana, 03/02/03

    Reply Index Next Previous Help



    | Behavior OnLine Home Page | Disclaimer |

    Copyright © 1996-2004 Behavior OnLine, Inc. All rights reserved.