Behavior OnLine EMDR FORUM ARCHIVE, 2000

    Re:Physical reactions
    Sandra Paulsen Inobe, PhD · 02/09/01 at 8:43 PM ET

    The particular variant you describe is new to me, but I can tell you that the subject of intense, transient physical or emotional discomfort is not at all unusual after EMDR.

    No one knows exactly what is going on, but I know what it looks like to me, having seen in innumerable times. It seems that the processing pulls out one or more BASK elements (behavior, affection, sensation, knowledge) associated with usually very early trauma. The session ends before the processing is complete, but the processing keeps "percolating", like an egg that keeps cooking after you take it out of the boiling water. Then the percolation causes another "piece" to work its way out of the body, and whammo! There is the intense experience as it comes out, like a burb, or a bubble that comes to the surface. It may be momentary or last for hours or even a day.

    Last week I had a client with a similar story, but her neck pulled her head sideways for a few hours, then it was gone.

    For those skeptics and scholars who question whether EMDR is a placebo or a simple variation of cbt/exposure therapy, how often do we hear stories like this about cbt and exposure? Never, I'll wager. This is an EMDR phenomenon.



    Replies:
    • Thanks, by A curious client, 02/10/01
    • Re:Physical reactions , by , 02/10/01
      • Re:Physical reactions , by Sandra Paulsen Inobe, PhD, 02/11/01
        • Re:Physical reactions , by , 02/11/01
          • Re:Physical reactions , by a client, 02/12/01
          • Re:Physical reactions , by Sandra Paulsen Inobe, PhD, 02/12/01
            • Re:Repressed memory information, by , 02/12/01
              • Re:Repressed memory information, by Sandra Paulsen Inobe, PhD, 02/12/01
              • Emergent traumatic material, by Sandra Paulsen Inobe, PhD, 02/12/01
                • Re:Emergent traumatic material, by , 02/12/01
                  • Re:Emergent traumatic material, by Cynthia Byrtus, 04/13/01
                  • Who are you?, by Diane, 02/14/02
              • Re:Repressed memory information-a different source, by , 02/12/01
              • Re:Repressed memory information, by a client, 02/12/01
                • Re:Repressed memory information, by Cynthia A. Byrtus, 04/13/01
          • Re:Physical reactions , by prefer unknown, 02/12/01
            • Re:Physical reactions , by Sandra Paulsen Inobe, PhD, 02/13/01
              • Re:Physical reactions , by by string originator, 02/16/01
                • Re:Physical reactions , by Robert P. O'Brien, Ph.D., 02/17/01
          • Re:Physical reactions , by Insider, 12/21/02
            • Re:Physical reactions , by , 12/22/02
              • Re:Physical reactions , by Insider, 12/22/02
              • Re:Physical reactions , by Insider, 12/22/02

    Reply Index Next Previous Help



    | Behavior OnLine Home Page | Disclaimer |

    Copyright © 1996-2004 Behavior OnLine, Inc. All rights reserved.