Sorry to burst your bubble!

I'm sorry to burst your bubble but I was under the impression that this was a discussion group for professionals (with lay people always being welcomed of course). There are 2 years of one sided messages for you to read through prior to my postings. This should provide you with more than enough info on what you are seeking. However, I thought this was a "discussion" group but you can't have a discussion with only one side being heard. Do the professionals on this list feel that controversial issues in EMDR should be pushed under the carpet and not discussed?

This is a discussion group so let's present the issues--both sides! Unless the professionals on this list are afraid of the evidence that is. I still look forward to at least one professional contradicting the comments I made in my original posting regarding EMDR and the evidence. We just keep getting off topic.

If not I must assume that the evidence does not support EMDR being any more than CBT with superfluous things added to appear new. If so, this is a real issue to discuss.

Thanks as always,

Brian

Replies:

Re: Sorry to burst your bubble!, by Teresa, 2/14/00 Thank you Teresa!, by Brian G., 2/14/00 Re: Thank you Teresa!, by Shapiro, 2/15/00 the discussion continues, by Brian G., 2/15/00 Re: the discussion continues, by Sandra Paulsen, Ph.D., 2/16/00 Re: Thank you Teresa!, by M.C.(an EDUCATED layperson) , 3/4/00 Re: Thank you Teresa!, by Don, 3/4/00 Re: Thank you Teresa!, by M.C., 3/4/00 Re: Thank you Teresa!, by Don, 3/5/00 Re: Thank you Teresa!, by another layperson, 3/7/00 Re: Thank you Teresa!, by Brian, 3/5/00 Re: Thank you Teresa!, by Another Layperson, 3/7/00 Re: Thank you Teresa!, by Don, 3/7/00

| Behavior OnLine Home Page | Disclaimer |

Copyright © 1996-2004 Behavior OnLine, Inc. All rights reserved.